Walkable neighbourhoods are green neighbourhoods
Winnipeg City Council has voted to support a referendum on the opening of Portage and Main during the fall election. Green Action Centre does not support the plebiscite for this infrastructure project, as no other road projects are put into the hands of citizen referendums. As noted by others, if Winnipeg had held a referendum on the Red River Floodway it would never have been built. We can also see “Portage and Main” is being used as a political wedge issue, diverting the campaign focus from other important issues such as homelessness, transit, mental health and addictions. However, since the referendum has been called, Green Action Centre wants to use this opportunity to engage the citizens of Winnipeg on the larger issue of how we build our roads, and how their design has traditionally prioritized the movement of cars over the movement of people.
Green Action Centre has always advocated for walkable, bikeable, transit-friendly neighbourhoods. As such, we encourage the City of Winnipeg, and all citizens, to place the safety and comfort of those walking, biking and taking transit above the convenience of those in personalized motor vehicles. We recognize the needs of large transport vehicles to move goods within city limits, but we do not support our dense urban centre putting the convenience of transport trucks ahead of safe, walkable neighbourhoods or those who live, work or play in our urban core.
Because Portage and Main is located in the middle of key neighbourhoods – St. Boniface, The Exchange District, Downtown and The Forks – we heartily support removing the barricades and redesigning the intersection so that it is truly accessible and reflects its identity as “the heart of the continent.”
Thank you to the Vote Open Winnipeg campaign for presenting the facts and figures around this intersection.
- 6,200: The number of cars that pass through the intersection at peak rush hour.
- 54: The average number of seconds added to an afternoon rush hour commute after pedestrians are reintroduced.
- 24: The average number of minutes in a Winnipeg commute.
- 18: The average number of seconds added to a morning rush hour commute after pedestrians are reintroduced.
- 400: The number of meters someone who can’t navigate stairs must travel to cross the street when the office buildings are closed.
- 9: The average number of minutes it takes to cross using a wheelchair in the underground.
- 4: The number of elevators someone must use when crossing underground in a wheelchair.
- 2: The number of ramps someone must use when crossing underground in a wheelchair.
- 4 million: Number of people attending events downtown every year.
- 800,000: Number of tourists that come to Winnipeg from outside of Manitoba each year.
- 110,000: Number of people who live, work or study downtown every day.
- 17,000: The number of downtown residents, up from 9,000 in the 1970’s.
- 15,000: The number of people who work within 100 meters of Portage and Main.
- 2,300: Number of hotel rooms downtown, with two more hotels under construction including one on Portage Avenue East.
- 2,000: The number of pedestrian crossings at Portage and Main anticipated by the City of Winnipeg in the busiest one hour of the day.
- 600: The number of new residents living Winnipeg’s tallest building (42 stories) under construction a block away from Portage and Main.
- 3 billion: The number of dollars invested in downtown Winnipeg in the last decade.
- 1 million: The anticipated construction cost to remove the barriers. This includes $2.3 million contingency to cover cost overruns.
- 82: The number of City of Winnipeg capital projects currently underway with a value of more than $5-million.
Why Vote Open
- Winnipeg has changed since 1979. We now have a booming Exchange District, revitalized Downtown, and The Forks has transitioned from a rail yard into a busy tourist hub, including the Canadian Museum for Human Rights and a new residential area that will be added in the next few years. Portage and Main is a natural connector of these areas. The fact that the intersection is now a vortex, with neglected surface parking lots and few people, speaks volumes about how the barricades have negatively impacted development in this area.
- Street design has changed since 1979. Planners will draw on designs from similar intersections around the world to create a beautiful cross-way that accommodates the smooth flow of pedestrians, buses and bikes through the intersection, as well as personal motor vehicles and trucks. Scramble crossings, transit priority lights, resyncing of lights, and many more design options are successfully used at similar intersections around the world.
- Traffic impacts will occur during rush hour times, or “peak periods” for a few hours a day and only for some users. Too often we design our intersections to accommodate the 10 hours a week of peak traffic, without considering the other 158 hours a week. Dating from the 1950s, the engineering perspective of a successful road design is based on how many motorized vehicles can pass through as quickly as possible during peak periods (‘rush hour’). Today’s standards recognize the goal is to move as many people as possible and using a variety of modes including transit, walking and cycling. Winnipeg continues to have a high rate of motorized vehicles with one person in the vehicle. By providing infrastructure that also ensures the comfort and safety of transit, biking and walking, Winnipeg can reduce the number of single occupancy vehicles and increase the number of people moving on our roads, thereby improving the efficiency of existing roads. Instead of building for the most inefficient means of moving people, the city should focus on efficiency and equity by offering real alternatives to those who would choose to use transit, bike or walk but currently feel they have “no choice” but to drive. (The pyramid diagram shown on this page is from https://www.visionzerostreets.org/)
- We can already see the interest people have in bussing, biking and walking. Despite our incomplete, unconnected cycling infrastructure, 20% of Winnipeggers say they currently bike regularly, while 35% would cycle more if conditions were better (CAA and Bike Winnipeg survey data). Green Action Centre’s Workplace Commuter Options program regularly engages with businesses, organizations and institutions in Winnipeg to conduct commuting surveys. When asked how they currently commute, workplaces often have a high number of employees who drive alone. When asked how they would PREFER to commute, the drive alone number falls dramatically, with transit, cycling and carpooling often being the preferred option. This is why all road projects should prioritize the safety and comfort of healthy, sustainable travellers first to capitalize on the large number of people who would choose to commute in another way. This is key to tackling congestion and reducing our GHG emissions.
- Portage and Main does not currently meet accessibility standards. In the data above, we can see how difficult it is for those with mobility issues to travel through, or around, the intersection. To have “the heart of the continent” not meet accessibility standards reflects poorly on us as a city. All citizens should be able to access and cross this intersection with dignity.
- Portage and Main has many safety issues due to the current design. As outlined by Jill Coubrough in Safety Concerns Have Women Calling for Portage and Main to be Reopened, the current design has many dark and poorly lit places that pose a risk to women and vulnerable people. Most importantly, the lack of street life creates the biggest safety, or perceived safety, barrier. We must always encourage design that increases the number of “eyes on the street” (Jane Jacobs). Further details on the benefits of walkability to neighbourhoods is outlined in CityLab`s Walkability Is Good For You.
- Opening Portage and Main will benefit the city financially, as the plethora of neglected surface parking lots will be more appealing to developers. The Downtown Winnipeg BIZ, The Exchange District BIZ and CentreVenture, as well as the owners of the four corner towers, support the opening of the intersection as they recognize that more people on foot and bike is good for business. With the barriers up, people are not using Portage and Main, the natural connector of neighbourhoods like The Exchange, The Forks, St. Boniface and Downtown, to travel. Currently, it is void of life. But restoring people to the blocks around the intersection will once again connect these neighbourhoods and create the conditions necessary for shops, cafes, food trucks and other ventures to set up shop. In fact, Portage and Main might not serve as just a natural connector, but as a destination.
- Our heart is already beating at Portage and Main. Whether it’s a Jets celebration, an Idle No More Protest, or a Human Flag to celebrate Canada Day, we flock to Portage and Main. The barriers have created an unnatural vortex, and we believe removing them will restore the natural energy of the intersection.
It’s time to restore life to Portage and Main. This October, we will all have a chance to vote Yes to:
- Levelling the playing field for Winnipeggers to walk, bike and bus over the convenience of single occupancy vehicles.
- Ensuring our city is accessible for people of all ages and abilities.
- Connecting the neighbourhoods and destinations that did not exist in 1979, when the barricades went up.
- Re-thinking how we prioritize the use of our streets, taking the full 168 hours of the week into consideration, not just 10 hours of ‘rush hour’ or peak travel.
- Analyzing the research and data in front of us as critical thinkers, and making a decision based on our collective well-being.
- Creating a downtown that is safe, vibrant and welcoming to those who live, work, and play in the neighbourhood each day, and to those who are visiting from around the world.
Referendums for projects like Portage and Main can create division among citizens. However, Green Action Centre welcomes the opportunity to engage in a conversation around how we want to build our city for today and the future. We want Winnipeg to be built for people to live, work and play in the city, instead of being designed for motorized vehicles.
We envision all Manitobans living green and living well, and we recognize that a big piece of that vision hinges on how our cities and towns are built.
Vote Open Winnipeg, P&M By The Numbers, https://voteopenwpg.ca/
Chicago Pedestrian Scramble, Chicago Daily News, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ndt_M3KKUBY
Transit Priority Lights, Let’s Talk Transit (Edmonton), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_QdXT6T8Tw
Transportation Priority Hierarchy, Vision Zero Streets, https://www.visionzerostreets.org/
More People Cycling Than Ever Before, CBC Manitoba, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-cyclists-poll-caa-1.4759579
Safety Concerns … , CBC Manitoba, https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/portage-main-women-safety-1.4760581
Walkability Is Good For You, CityLab, https://www.citylab.com/design/2014/12/growing-evidence-shows-walkability-is-good-for-you-and-for-cities/383612/
Walkable Cities Are Better For Our Health And Economy, The Globe and Mail, https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/walkable-cities-are-better-for-our-health-and-economy/article36384880/
How Bicycles Bring Business, Momentum, https://momentummag.com/how-bicycles-bring-business/